Share Video
Download Video: Click Here (save as ***.flv) | Real Player or any FLV Player Required
Permalink:
Embed Code:
wtfbroskie Says:
Nov 20, 2009 - lmao
skullndroses Says:
Nov 20, 2009 - chilling... peaking on ecstasy listening to this version for the first time was something.
pfergz Says:
Nov 20, 2009 - Roger's part in this song gives me chills every time. i would give a lot of things to see these guys live back in their day. RIP Rick Wright, Syd Barret
timechannel Says:
Nov 21, 2009 - Lesson No1 - How to create atmosphere and build to a climax
DoctorPencilK Says:
Nov 21, 2009 - Everytime Roger makes that high-pitched scream, you just want to kick him in the nads to see if those scream really are his.
redsox152 Says:
Nov 22, 2009 - it could be better with a few more vocal parts in it other than just screaming and mubling
frm420wthlove Says:
Nov 22, 2009 - its perfect the way it is
thephantomlord13 Says:
Nov 22, 2009 - Does this song represent a fight between good and evil inside the mind of all human beings?
Gizmogibbongimp Says:
Nov 22, 2009 - Careful with that Axe always seems to remind me of One of my Turns from the Wall, as he refrences an axe.
lump215 Says:
Nov 23, 2009 - hey redsox152. fuck yourself
jamarchand Says:
Nov 23, 2009 - Great video. The only four members at stage. That was the real live show. Since the 80ths, Pink Floyd decided for Mega shows, using tons of another musicians at stage, supporting the band. Two or three drummers, percusionists, women's backing vocals, 2 keybordists, 2 or 3 guitarrists....so much staff. To me, this is NOT honest. A little "army" to play live. Why Pink Floyd had fear to play with the only four members at stage? Fear of mistakes? This is the part of the show.
aymeric27 Says:
Nov 23, 2009 - at Iive at Pompei they were alone... And they just rocked !
nofrils Says:
Nov 23, 2009 - jamarchand: What are you talking about? Fear of errors you kidding me prior to the 80 they has 20 years of live stage ROCK AND FREAKING ROLE and you are telling that after that they suddenly developed fear lmao ohhh boy. The problem is you don't understand what Floyd is about Floyd was always ALWAYS about big Rock shows think of the Wall just 4 guys putting on the larges Rock show EVER!!!!! even to this day its epic is scale.
jamarchand Says:
Nov 23, 2009 - I'm telling that....to play the older songs...such Echoes, Saucerful Of Secrets, Shine On Your Crazy Diamond, Dogs, Time, ao...is absolutelly enough play with the only foru members. The opera-rock pink floy era is boring...and they put a lot of musicians on the live shows. To me..this is not the band. Is just several people playing togheter. I love PF as a quartet...not as an orchestra.
jamarchand Says:
Nov 23, 2009 - Led Zeppelin was always played with only the BAND. Just the four. And the shows were always great. The same on Rush and many other bands. Pitty that PF abandoned and placed the instrospective shows for mega BUT edulcorated concerts.
JonnyCashmore Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - dont ever mention RUSH in the same sentence as Pink FLoyd ever again........................yo weak fool....RUSH SUCKs. Pink Floyd and Zeppelin are great
JonnyCashmore Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - Jamarchand......dont speak agai here ever.....let me guess. Neil Peart s the best.......yet Vinnie kills him. Geddy's wicked......yet Jaco eats him for lunch. Lifeson......do I really need to say anymore?..................
lauta91 Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - What do you have against rush man? Maybe Peart is not the best, but say that it's too much... Rush it's one of the greatest progressive and hard rock icons.... you cant say that rush its worse than zeppelin, listen 2112, carres of steel, hemispheres, and learn... but in the fact, floyd was and is the best..
jamarchand Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - Calm down, Mr. Jonny. I've never said Rush is better or worse than Pink Floyd. I suggest that yoy READ correctly my text. I ONLY said that Rush, Led Zeppelin and other bands naver added supporting musicians at the stage for the live shows. Beyond that, I love Pink Floyd more than Rush or Led. This is OLNY may personnal taste. The comentary here is about the exagerated uses of extra-musicians in the live show.
jamarchand Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - One more thing. Weak fool is a person who wants to rule the other opinions here in YT. This is a FREE forum. Do you know the meaning of FREE? And you are free do agree or desagree other opinions...but your wish on rule them is just a childish behaviour. Grow up, Mr. Jonny....and learn to READ the texts.
teoganz Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - questa è LA musica.
Smurf17420 Says:
Nov 24, 2009 - Yea Rush licks nuts compared to Pink Floyd lol
cheping Says:
Nov 25, 2009 - @JonnyCashmore you're at the same level of Jonas Bros fans that posted earlier on this site. Rush is a great band, not at Led Zeppelin or Pink Floyd level but for sure worthy to be mention near them.
Ph0b0ph1l3 Says:
Nov 25, 2009 - Rush licks no nuts... They rock too. but less than pink floyd...



frm420wthlove Says:
Nov 20, 2009 - wht is roger singing about...? weird as usual, mind blowing guitar