Share Video

Download Video: Click Here (save as ***.flv) | Real Player or any FLV Player Required

Permalink:

Embed Code:

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 5, 2009 - But you are assuming that every women will be married. As you know, 50% gets divorce and some are still single. So your logical explanation is still not fair, and we all assume that God is always fair. I don't see the fairness at all, so still what is the reason for women takes half, given that she will not be connected with any men!

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - Not really my friend! I am not talking only about married women; I said sisters..daughters..even if one does not have a brother or a father her cousin, or uncle must be responsible..if these women don't have a supporter the country must be the supporter..we are not talking about married women..

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - so..as a woman I would take half what a man takes, and by the way there are many time where women take exactly as the man in Islam... and when I take this half to put it in my pocket..but the man has to support me..yet the problem is that women DO NOT ASK FOR THEIR RIGHTS AND SOME MEN ARE TOTALLY UNFAIR..IT'S NOT Allah not being fair...it's people..

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - You are trying to justify men taking double the women, however any elementary student will tell you that this is not fair! If math is not working for you, nothing well. Live in your dilution. BTW, if the Quran says, men take exactly like women, or take two third, I will heard the same bias opinion. Anyway, moving on, since you are not good in math. How about Adam Eve? What I am trying to simply tell you is, there are lots of stories that can be proven wrong, but you will never admit it.

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - I am not trying to justify it because it is totally logical.again i wouldn't give someone exactly as the other if this person is not goona be finnancially responsible to support any family..and this fair for men as well..and because Allah is so fair there are cases where a woman takes exactly like a man

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - aND WHAT ABOUT ADAM AND EVE? Now there are things that we can prove logically, like the existnece of God by looking around in this creation and the miraculous organization of every single atom in the universe..don't tell me that no one built all this!! that would be stuipid! sorry but this is the truth..again your case of inheritence is totally weak ..just read the link please!!

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - And please...these topics, though important, are not related tot he video..there are many other places where you can discuss them..honestly..it is better to read and search instead of simply stating something..whatever you say are stereotypes all non muslims repeat..

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - Logical to you (or any Muslim) is not the proper English. Logic is the art and science of reason. Your reason can work at certain time (back when women wasn't working, or wasn't financially responsible, now they are, please you are not a woman, so spare us your men's opinion), but that reason is not valid any more (if it were ever valid that is another point I wouldn't go into). Allah is not fair, otherwise, he would ask to split equal, that is fair man!

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - You know, I was a Muslim, if I argue with any non-Muslim, I have to make sure no one laugh at me. You are saying that "Biology" is stupid! I have news for you, yes, life can be as diverse as it is with slow progress or mutation and selection. You didn't study biology, why don't you watch the small introduction that I sent you about biology then we talk! I wish to argue with an educated (educated means read a bit of biology) Muslim, where are they????

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - أخي يبدو أنك ستظل تدور في دوائر..ما ردك على ما قرأته في الرابط الذي أرسلته بخصوص الميراث؟! طبعا لن تتمكن من الإجابة-هذا إذا قرأته-

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - وإذا رغبت في الحديث مع "عالم" يمكنك أن تقرأ للبروفيسور زغلول النجار-مصري مسلم- وله موقعه عن الحقائق العلمية الموجودة في القرآن والتي لم يكن لمحمد صلى الله عليه وسلم النبي الأمي أن يأتي بها ..

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - ما رأيك مثلا في سورة الحديد؟ أتحداك أن تنقضها حيث تأكدت من حقائقها بنفسي..وهذه آخر مرة أناقشك فيها في موضوع خارج هذا الفيديو وقد زودتك بكل الروابط فأرجو أن تقرأها ورجاء التزم بالموضوع حيث أني سألغي ما لا علاقة له بالفيديو وشكرا

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - yes, I can't talk with someone who is telling me 2 is exactly equal to 1 and it is fair !!!! Give me a break!

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - No need to speak with a professor, just someone who doesn't say biology is stupid.

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - I am not going to argue with every single piece of the Quran. I had some questions and those questions were obviously answered wrongly according to the "common" logic, that is why I left the religion. Some of the Quran writing is nice and moral, but that doesn't mean that there is God and we should pray and all this package around it. I am a Kafr now, and I don't kill anyone or rape or steal or burn houses just because I don't have religion, doesn't mean I am a bad person. Salam to all

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - You are not going to argue because you cannot! I answered and MATHEMATICALLY inheritence laws are 100% fair..if some muslims are bad it does not mean Allah is bad or Islam is bad..you call yourself kafir, which is not really a nice word..I think you are a good person seeking the truth..an I DID NOT SAY A SINGLE BAD WORD ABOUT YOU..!

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - Sir, no body attacked you here,,I just wish you would do one thing for you not for me: Pray one prayer the way you want and say: If there is a God..hear me please and let me find the truth..I am sure one day you will come back coz, as you said, you are a good person..

ISMASHYOUBRO Says:

Nov 9, 2009 - Dude you have little knowledge. about Islam. If you want to learn about it go watch some Ahmed Deedat or just search up some videos. I think it would really help you. I researched the Quran out of curiosity and when looked at in clear light it is amazing.

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 9, 2009 - i hope you don't mean me by this! :)

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 10, 2009 - What is so amazing about it, it has a lot of repetition, false facts that are too obvious to be wrong for any non-Muslim, example:- ( وَجَعَلْنَا السَّمَاء سَقْفًا مَّحْفُوظًا) this is obviously getting the concept of the sky absolutely wrong, yes it looks like it 2000 years ago, but we all know that it is all empty space, there is no limit, there is no roof. If you still believe in that, just don't tell you kids, they will laugh at you

ISMASHYOUBRO Says:

Nov 10, 2009 - There are really no false facts. What is funny is that many people are looking at it scientifically when there are many parts that are quite poetic. I hope you do realize some of the Quran's science miracles. Many try to debunk them but they are nothing more than false statements such as 'It's too vague'. or 'it could mean a million things' which is laughable sometimes. I think you should watch the Divine Book series. Salaam.

xxxxmuslim Says:

Nov 10, 2009 - "No false facts", now I know who I am talking to. Here is a false fact, there are n Gods, they control everything. Some say, if there are more than one God, they will fight, hell no, they are nice Gods, they don't fight. Well, looks like you will believe that stuff too. LOL... Salam ya Canadian...

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 10, 2009 - now you do not want to speak to an educated person? you see..you also need a lesson in math..it is not fair to give two people the exact amount of money then say for the first one to be financially responsible for the second one! now this is not fair and you do not want to see that..so suit yourself and please do not talk about it anymore in my page

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 10, 2009 - dear ISMASH...kindly do not argue with someone who woud not dare confront you when you mention SCIENTIFIC MIRACLES IN QURAN..I DARED HIM to watch the video about mentioning iron in Quran and he keeps escaping from it! it is the video entitled: معجزة إنزال الحديد في القرآن so don't waste your time and thanks for passing by..

Eliaziah Says:

Nov 17, 2009 - sorry rgfvdshgfegfdghffg i had to remove your comment..I know you are angry because of what that guy said,,but remember! being a Muslim means no bad words...thanks for passing by and welcome to comment in a positive way..