dajohnreams Says:

Sep 7, 2009 - that and dumbledore knew the whole time that draco would kill him so in the end,(spoiler) he told snape to kill him cause he knew draco couldn't

Deirdrre Says:

Sep 16, 2009 - JUST READ THE BOOK THAN :P if you want to know

MusicFan20011 Says:

Sep 16, 2009 - Be sure to read Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince book before watching the movie. It'll prepare you for Dumbledore's death scene so you may not cry as much, also the movie left some stuff out so you will find that out in the book. Please Read the series if you haven't already, you'll find out information that the movies left out and the books are awesome just like the movies.

rdeand82 Says:

Sep 16, 2009 - Voldemort, En La Ultima pelicula Harry Potter and the deathly hallows.. Voldemort va a querer Matar A Harry Despues De que Cumpla los 17 . en ese moment , Harry Perdera , Toda la Proteccion dada por su madre . Ahora , El puede hacer magia, pero quien lo defendera ¿? revivira dumbledore ?. bueno , en los libros dice que no. Pero segun el Creador De Las peliculas Harry Potter . si van a cambiar algunas esenas. Quiere decir que no le agan mucha atencion al libro.

Onagalord Says:

Sep 26, 2009 - i read the 6th book im in the middle of the 7th book now

WinCamVista Says:

Sep 27, 2009 - wheres the part where Dumbledore is actually killed? the chase? when hes falling? its dramatic i cant believe its not here!

Mayaiskoolieeo Says:

Oct 6, 2009 - Dumbledore knew he would die, and he knew about Malfoy, so he asked Snape to do it instead so Draco wouldn't be cursed forever

xLondonCalling Says:

Oct 7, 2009 - Just to get it all straight for the people who only watch the movies and don't read the books: Dumbledore was dying slowly and in the last book you can read a conversation in Snapes head in which Dumbledore asks Snape to kill him instead of Draco. Untill Harry has seen this conversation he hates Snape and wishes he could kill him. Sorry if I made mistakes grammaticely I'm only dutch after all.

MrPansyMalfoy Says:

Oct 11, 2009 - beutiful video i love harry potter

ephimer Says:

Oct 11, 2009 - well if you see the movie again you´ll see this track appears during the whole conversation between draco and dumbledore and the ending of this track is when snape appears and says "NO!" after that he kills him and another piece of short music appeasr while he falls...it is not here altough. so this track isnt really the killing exactly, actually it could be named "THE ASTRONOMY TOWER" and it would have worked better for people would not be spoiled.

ephimer Says:

Oct 11, 2009 - Tom´s acting in this scene was gorgeous!!!

nevfx Says:

Oct 17, 2009 - The only mistake was it was Snapes memory, not "in his head".

nevfx Says:

Oct 17, 2009 - So Dracos soul wouldnt be split, which murder cause. He also implied Snapes soul would not be damaged as it was a "mercy killing" in there case.

crahlo Says:

Oct 21, 2009 - SPOILERS IDIOT!!!

killket Says:

Oct 24, 2009 - i feel bad for snape and draco

IhateLegg Says:

Oct 24, 2009 - DUDE (or GIRL) Don't say that! The seventh movie hasn't come out yet to reveal that! D: *p.s., ive read the books. just don't go around spilling out spoilers from the seventh book :l

xLondonCalling Says:

Oct 26, 2009 - I don't see the problem in telling spoilers?

IhateLegg Says:

Oct 26, 2009 - Well if I only watched the movies, I wouldn't want to know what happens in the next movie before i've seen it.

xLondonCalling Says:

Oct 26, 2009 - Not really my problem is it.. every decent hp fan reads the books.

IhateLegg Says:

Oct 27, 2009 - yes, but there are some people like my sister who are too busy with their life to read the books but love the movies. it would just be nice to keep them to yourself and to your hp fan friends :)

UltimateBooknerd Says:

Oct 31, 2009 - I think that I love you! ^_^ lol. I agree completely. (:

UltimateBooknerd Says:

Oct 31, 2009 - Hmm....I'm pretty busy myself, but I make time. Read the book. It's always better. I make time. Sorry but if you don't read the books there will be spoilers. Get over it.

IhateLegg Says:

Oct 31, 2009 - Actually if you saw the earlier comments i made, i said "*p.s., ive read the books. just don't go around spilling out spoilers from the seventh book :l* It's just that some people will get pretty pissed if they hear spoilers.

UltimateBooknerd Says:

Nov 1, 2009 - I agree with London. There should be no problem telling spoliers. You should already know what happens....seriously, people ought to read the book. Also I'm not calling you out for not reading the book, I'm just saying why I don't see a problem with spoilers. They can be pissed, it's not my fault they didn't read the book. :\ That's what you get for just watching the movie...

IhateLegg Says:

Nov 1, 2009 - Well, this little argument has gone long enough. We're obviously not on the right track, so what is the point in arguing when we know that it'll never resolve the way either of us want it? I respect your opinion and you should respect mine too. I do think that people should read the book, but even if they don't, they still don't "deserve" to be spoiled. That's my final word.