Doctor Who - Old vs. New.

gimzod76 Says:

Nov 1, 2009 - real reason the old series is better than the new?? the old series doesn't have love and monsters in it.

dmt3412 Says:

Nov 2, 2009 - The Five Doctors.

alexkrycek21 Says:

Nov 2, 2009 - Both Classic and New Who have their good and bad points. However there are some Classic stories like Genesis of the Daleks, Caves of Androzani, City of Death and Pyramids of Mars which the new series haven't got anywhere near. The new series could do with going to more planets. Also feel the Daleks could be a bit more ruthless sometimes, like they were in the first series.

chrisaira Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - yeah i mean just look at the series 4 finale 2 exterminations, Jack and Suzanne were killed, Jack came back, honestly, 2! Just look at the episodes Dalek and Parting of the Ways, Extermination City, or underground base/sattelite, whatever u call them

chrisaira Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - i quite enjoyed love and monsters, it was interesting to see how the dr had cropped up and got noticedd bu the most ordinary of people

chrisaira Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - love and monsters, the unquiet dead, shaksepare code, TUATW, Boom Town and Utopia- none of these were wastes, Fear Her was OK, but o would rather have seen a more imaginative story, allthough i completely disagree when dr who magazine said there should have been NO olympics i mean come on, the dr lighting the omypmic flame, AWESOME, and the Terminator style cliffhanger was good but still Fear Her = least good episode in new series

chrisaira Says:

Nov 6, 2009 - in thje new series the drcries about the time lords being gone all the time, but confusingly in classic dr who- the dr couldnt give a monkeys f*** if the time lords died, i dont even like the time lords, theyre like, ignorant b******, theyre a cool part of the plot but i dnt like their characters, especially that Inquistitor and Borusa, t**** the 2 of em

gallafey Says:

Nov 7, 2009 - message to the producers new doctor who, let's see the go off to more far distant planets, in theold serires the doctor often spoke about his companions like Jamie, Jo Grant, Romana, even his granddaughter susan

MALShortsClub Says:

Nov 10, 2009 - Now I remember why I was so scared when I was a kid

bazookoidben Says:

Nov 13, 2009 - Perhaps the approach was a little skewed, I think thats why most people had an aversion to it. But it's an interesting concept that we haven't seen before. How peoples lives are effected buy just the Doctor appearing, I do like it, and I think the best moment of the episode is just where Elton and the Doctor sit down at the end to talk about how his mother died.

bazookoidben Says:

Nov 13, 2009 - The Daleks need a little umph put back in them, I agree. "Evolution" did that to a degree, I consider it quite a classical feeling episode that lends it self very nicely to the classic series. Though I think we will really move to the dark end of the spectrum now that Moffat is master of all, he knows how to make a proper Who story. Look at Blink or The Empty Child, fantastic episodes.

chrisaira Says:

Nov 13, 2009 - finally, someone who isnt a 40 year oldpedophile, on this video someone who actuallty has respect, thank you :) I think Love and Moonsters was a good episode, it intodcued a fasinating conecpt, andi love that guy who made the absorbaloff, i could kiss him, except i wont, cos, hes a boy, but hes a very imaginative person.

BastardProductions Says:

Nov 13, 2009 - problems with this video: a) Bias: Most of the things you praise classic who for actually occur in new Who as well, as if there has never been an exploding dalek or on screen death in new who! and vice versa (even Revelation of the Daleks, which you keep turning to, has a strong love story element, and lets not forget the Doctor's refusal to destroy the Daleks in Genesis, surely the biggest act of compassion ever?)

BastardProductions Says:

Nov 13, 2009 - b) you favour the exceptionally bad episodes of new who, rather than a balanced view of the series (Last of the Time Lords, Fear Her) plus most of the classic clips are from rubbish stories (ressurection of the daleks, the TV movie), hardly a testament to classic who's greatness... c) its a very juvenile view of the classic show any way... if you want explosions and violence then watch a Chuck Norris movie

casettetapir Says:

Nov 17, 2009 - i never watched a bigger piece of shit in my life whats the point of watching something just so you can conplain thats its not as good as it used to be stop living in the past and lern to acsept dr who for what it is a great program then and now!!!

davros667788 Says:

Nov 17, 2009 - theres more bad new who than classic who

davros667788 Says:

Nov 17, 2009 - its no where ner as good as what t was, we dont have to accept it theyre ut on dvd so ha!

GizmoGardenia Says:

Nov 17, 2009 - "cry baby cry make your mother sigh"

Urkmigraft Says:

Nov 20, 2009 - If the old classic series was so good, why was it cancelled? And why is this new series sooo popular? Hmm?

SgtGarbel Says:

Nov 21, 2009 - I don't recall the classic series Doctor ever boasting about how he put his cock into members of the Royal Family. Dear God, the new series is drivel. That's why its popular, the same reason your X Factors and your Transformers are drivel -the plebs will watch any old shit if it's hyped enough.

freeride13 Says:

Nov 23, 2009 - this video is thew biggest load of biased crap ever. All u did was picked the sappy parts of the new series and made it look lame. There is loads of action in the new series!!! People die all the time and theres always guns and explosions ALSO racism was done in family of blood/human nature with martha getting insulted for being black. And in shakesperean code when she asked if she was going to get, "cast into slavery" So putting the old series to rock music doesnt make it better

freeride13 Says:

Nov 23, 2009 - as for the new dr not insulting the humans? how many times did he call them stupid apes? and the whole stupid planet? and ur thick? And ur telling me that the living dead, the weeping angels, and the gas mask zombies, didnt scare children???

Marshmallowmann Says:

Nov 24, 2009 - i think the new ones are pretty good.

fedorapandemic Says:

Nov 24, 2009 - Meh. There are definately still plenty of good new who. It's not all bad. i mean, I definately want to shoot Martha, and Rose as well sometimes...but not ALL the time. And anyway, there's lots of death in Torchwood if you want to see more of that stuff.

TakunaNuva Says:

Nov 25, 2009 - While you're kinda too overtly one-sided, I have to agree that the new series is, for the most part, a big mash of bad writing and emotion. Sure, there were cracking episodes, like Blink and the Empty Child... But most are just lacking the intrigue of the original show... (And yes, it's way too PC but that's not the makers' fault.) I must say I also dislike the whole new Dr. HUmanist, where he bursts out into a gushy speech at every chance. And don't get me started on the Deus ex Screwdriver...